The Best Premium Gas Grills: 4 Compared (and One to Skip)

RBE top pick

Weber Genesis S-415

Check price on Amazon See why it wins Compare all

The Weber Genesis S-415 lands the value-premium sweet spot: flagship-grade build and a deep warranty without flagship pricing. The Broil King Regal S590 Pro is the pick if searing power and an included rotisserie matter more to you than Weber's parts network.

Once you climb past the big-box specials, the money goes into things you can't see in a store: the thickness of the firebox, the metal in the burners, how the grates hold heat, and how long the warranty really covers. We read independent testing and years of owner reports to sort four genuinely premium grills into buy, consider, and skip. The short version: one brand nails the value-premium sweet spot, one is a searing-and-rotisserie standout, one flagship is more grill than most people need, and one respected name is coasting on its outdoor-kitchen reputation.

RBE top pick

Weber

Weber Genesis S-415

Buy it

The value-premium standard: four stainless PureBlu burners, a boostable Sear Zone, and 12 years on the cookbox for less than a flagship.

Best for: Most people who want a grill that sears well and lasts a decade without paying flagship money.

$$$ · premium

Why we like it

• Four stainless steel PureBlu burners at 48,000 BTU, with Boost Mode adding 40 percent more power in the Sear Zone
• 7mm stainless steel Weber Crafted grates and stainless Flavorizer bars
• Weber lists 12 years on the cookbox and lid and 10 years on the burners, grates and Flavorizer bars
• 646 square inches of primary cooking area, 820 with the warming rack

Know before buying

• No side burner, only two side tables, one of them a Weber Works drop-in table for accessories sold separately
• No rotisserie burner is listed

Check price on Amazon Read our detailed assessment ↓

Broil King

Broil King Regal S590 Pro

Buy it

A searing-and-rotisserie machine with extra-heavy reversible stainless grids, a side burner, and a rear rotisserie burner standard.

Best for: Sear-chasers and rotisserie cooks who want maximum heat and features for a premium (not flagship) price.

$$$ · premium

Why we like it

• Five stainless steel Dual-Tube burners put out strong direct heat
• Extra-heavy reversible stainless grids give you two cooking surfaces
• A side burner and a 15,000 BTU rear rotisserie burner with a rotisserie kit are included, not upsells
• 304 stainless cook box with cast-aluminum end caps, backed by a limited lifetime cook box warranty and 15 years on remaining parts and paint

Know before buying

• Broil King's own page lists it as available soon, with both the propane and natural gas variants sold out, so check stock before planning around it
• Owners occasionally report finicky ignition and heavier assembly than a Weber

Check price on Amazon Read our detailed assessment ↓

Weber

Weber Summit FS38 S

It depends

Weber's flagship is superbly equipped, but it's a lot of burners and money for capacity most households never use.

Best for: Frequent entertainers and big families who will genuinely use five burners, the infrared broiler, and rotisserie.

$$$$ · flagship

Why we like it

• Top-down infrared broiler (16,000 BTU) for searing
• Five PureBlu burners (65,000 BTU main input) plus a 12,000 BTU side burner suit high-volume cooking and entertaining
• Integrated rotisserie and a stainless smoker box are both included
• Weber's parts network and support are easy to find

Know before buying

• Costs far more than a Genesis while the core cooking experience is similar for most meals
• Big footprint (about 71 inches wide); the extra burners are wasted on typical weeknight grilling
• The propane version is listed as out of stock on Weber's page

Check price on Amazon Read our detailed assessment ↓

We'd skip it

Bull

Bull Angus

Skip it

A respected outdoor-kitchen name at a flagship price, but owner reports on heat evenness and real-world support lag a Weber or Broil King.

Best for: Built-in island projects where matching a Bull outdoor-kitchen aesthetic outranks pure cooking value.

$$$$ · flagship

Why we like it

• Genuine outdoor-kitchen looks and a familiar built-in brand
• 304 stainless steel body, and the maker lists lifetime coverage on the insert assembly, grates and cast stainless burners
• Available as a drop-in head or on a cart for island builds

Know before buying

• Owners frequently report uneven heat and hot spots versus similarly priced Weber/Broil King
• Lid and ignition reliability complaints show up in owner reports
• Warranty looks generous on paper but service experiences are mixed
• You're paying a flagship price partly for the outdoor-kitchen badge

See our pick instead See it at Amazon anyway Read our detailed assessment ↓

How we judged the field

We don’t run our own grilling lab. Instead, we synthesize owner reports and maker specifications, then weigh them against what actually makes a grill premium rather than just expensive. Five things did most of the sorting.

• Firebox and hood build. A sturdier cook box is a big part of the jump from big-box to premium, because it holds heat and helps even out the temperature across the grates. That tends to matter more than raw BTU numbers.
• Burner and grate material. Heavy stainless or cast burners outlast the thin tubes on cheap grills, and heat-holding grates (porcelain-enameled cast iron or thick stainless) are what actually put a sear on food. More burners only help if the metal and the firebox behind them are good.
• Sear and rotisserie hardware. A dedicated sear zone or infrared burner and a rear rotisserie burner are the features enthusiasts genuinely use, when they use them at all.
• Ignition reliability. A grill you have to coax to light is a daily annoyance. Owner reports are the best signal here, and they vary more by brand than the spec sheets suggest.
• Warranty depth and parts. Premium should mean years of coverage on the cook box, burners, and grates, plus a parts network so wear items are a quick fix, not a reason to replace the whole grill.

Against those criteria, one grill offered the most premium-for-the-money, two earned their price for specific buyers, and one asked flagship money without backing it up.

The Genesis S-415 is the value-premium pick in this group and the stainless Genesis Weber currently sells. It runs four stainless steel PureBlu burners at 48,000 BTU, and turning the red Boost Burner knobs to Boost Mode adds 40 percent more power in what Weber calls the largest Sear Zone in its class. The grates are 7mm stainless steel and flip over to take Weber Crafted grillware, the Flavorizer bars are stainless, and the primary cooking area is 646 square inches, 820 with the warming rack. Weber lists 12 years on the cookbox and lid, 10 years on the burner tubes, grates and Flavorizer bars, and 5 years on the remaining parts, and its parts network means wear items are easy to replace years later.

The trade-offs are in the extras. There is no side burner, just two side tables, one of them a Weber Works table built for drop-in accessories sold separately, and no rotisserie burner is listed. At a stated 175 pounds it is also a grill you place once. For most buyers, that’s the right place to spend, and the right place to stop.

If your priority is searing power and rotisserie, the Regal S590 Pro is the one to cross-shop. Broil King builds it around five stainless steel Dual-Tube burners, and it tops them with extra-heavy reversible stainless grids. The side burner and the 15,000 BTU rear rotisserie burner with its rotisserie kit are standard rather than upsells, and the cook box is 304 stainless with cast-aluminum end caps. Broil King backs it with a limited lifetime cook box warranty and 15 years on remaining parts and paint.

The trade-offs are real but manageable. Assembly is heavier than a Weber, a minority of owners report finicky ignition, and Broil King’s page currently lists it as available soon, so check stock. None of that undermines the core proposition: for a premium (not flagship) price, this is the most rotisserie capability on the list. It’s a genuine buy for cooks who chase a crust.

The Summit is not a bad grill, it’s an excellent one, and that’s exactly why it needs a careful verdict. Weber lists five PureBlu burners (65,000 BTU main input), a 12,000 BTU side burner, a 16,000 BTU top-down infrared broiler, an included integrated rotisserie, and an included stainless smoker box. If you cook for a crowd every weekend and will actually light all those burners, it’s a joy.

The problem is value for a typical household. For most meals, the cooking experience is likely close to what a Genesis delivers, yet the Summit costs substantially more and takes up considerably more space. You’re paying for capacity and extras, not a better sear on a weeknight steak. Buy it if you’re an entertainer who will use every feature; if you’re rationalizing the burners you’ll rarely light, the Genesis gets you most of the way for much less. That gap is the whole ‘is premium worth it’ question in one grill.

Bull has a real reputation in built-in outdoor kitchens, and the Angus looks the part. But judged as a cooking appliance at its price, it’s where premium tips into paying for the badge. Bull lists a 304 stainless steel body, piezo ignition, and lifetime coverage on the insert assembly, grates and cast burners, yet owner reports flag uneven heat and hot spots and ignition reliability complaints. The warranty reads generously on paper, but real-world service experiences are mixed, which is the opposite of what you want at this tier.

Stack it against a Weber or a Broil King at the same money and, going by owner reports, it loses on heat evenness and support you can count on. The one scenario where it makes sense is an island build where matching a Bull outdoor-kitchen aesthetic genuinely matters more than cooking value. For a freestanding grill you’re choosing on merit, we’d skip it.

Weber Genesis S-415 vs Broil King Regal S590 Pro: which should you buy?

These two are the real decision for most premium buyers, and they split cleanly. The Genesis S-415 is the all-rounder: four stainless burners, a Sear Zone with Boost Mode, electronic ignition, and Weber’s parts-and-warranty safety net. It’s the grill we’d hand to someone who wants to buy once and forget about it.

The Regal S590 Pro is the specialist. It out-features the Weber for the same tier, with a rear rotisserie burner and kit included plus extra-heavy reversible stainless grids. The cost is heavier assembly and, per some owners, less predictable ignition. Choose the Broil King if searing and rotisserie are the reasons you’re upgrading; choose the Genesis if you value even, fuss-free everyday cooking and the confidence that you’ll find a replacement burner in ten years. Neither is a mistake.

What to look for

• A sturdy cook box that holds heat and resists warping.
• Heavy grates that hold heat, such as porcelain-enameled cast iron or thick stainless; match the material to how much upkeep you’ll tolerate.
• A real sear zone or infrared burner only if you’ll use it; a strong main-burner sear covers most cooking.
• A rear rotisserie burner if roasts and whole chickens are on your menu, otherwise skip the premium for it.
• Heat-diffusion bars or plates over the burners to tame flare-ups.
• Reliable ignition, judged by owner reports as much as the spec sheet.
• Multi-year warranty on the cook box, burners, and grates, plus a brand with a parts network.
• Right-sized capacity: don’t pay for burners and cabinet space you won’t use.

Our final take

Premium gas grills earn their money when it goes into the firebox, the burners, the grates, and the warranty, and they waste it when it goes into badge, bulk, or gimmicks. The Weber Genesis S-415 concentrates the spend where it counts and is our pick for most people. The Broil King Regal S590 Pro is the better buy if you want maximum searing and an included rotisserie at the same tier. The Weber Summit FS38 S is genuinely excellent but only worth its flagship price if you’ll use its capacity. And the Bull Angus is the cautionary tale: a premium price that leans on reputation more than results. Buy for how you actually cook, and ‘premium’ will feel like value instead of a splurge.

Deciding between the top two? See our head-to-head: Weber Genesis S-415 vs Broil King Regal S590 Pro.

More in Garden & Outdoor Living

Premium Gas Grills, Explained Plain-English guide → Weber Genesis S-415 vs Broil King Regal S590 Pro Head-to-head → The Best Electric Pressure Washers for Home Use: 4 Compared (and One to Skip) The Best Pruning Shears: 6 Compared (and One to Skip) Raised Garden Beds: Which to Buy and Which to Skip The Best Robot Lawn Mowers: 4 Compared (and One to Skip)