Which Lawn Spreader Should You Buy?

RBE top pick

Brinly 50 LB. Push Spreader with Side Deflector & Hopper Cover (P20-500BHDF-A)

Check price on Amazon See why it wins Compare all

The Brinly pairs big pneumatic tires, an enclosed gearbox, stainless hardware and an included side deflector with a 2-year warranty and US manufacture. The EarthWay costs less and has side-spread control and pneumatic tires, but carries a 1-year warranty and a smaller 40 lb hopper.

A spreader decides whether fertilizer, seed and weed control land evenly or in stripes, and whether the driveway gets a dose too. Most homeowners want a push broadcast spreader, which throws granules in a wide arc from a spinning plate, while small yards can get by with a handheld. The differences that matter are hopper size, tires, edge control, a sealed gearbox and what the maker will stand behind. We compared four push broadcast spreaders, one battery handheld, and the best-known big-box spreader, using only each maker's own product pages.

RBE top pick

Brinly

Brinly 50 LB. Push Spreader with Side Deflector & Hopper Cover (P20-500BHDF-A)

Buy it

A US-made 50 lb push broadcast spreader with big pneumatic tires, stainless hardware and a side deflector included.

Best for: Homeowners with typical suburban lawns who want a sturdy spreader with edge control included and a longer warranty.

$$$ · premium

Why we like it

• Brinly lists 12 x 3 inch pneumatic turf tires, a powder-coated steel frame, stainless steel hardware and a rust-resistant enclosed gearbox.
• A flip-up side deflector kit and hopper screen come in the box, so you can keep fertilizer and salt off beds and paving without buying extras.
• It states an 8 to 12 ft spread width, is made in the USA and carries a 2-year warranty.

Know before buying

• It costs the most of the push spreaders here.
• The gears are plastic, at a 5:1 ratio, rather than metal.
• The 50 lb hopper means more refills than the 80 and 85 lb models on big lawns.

Check price on Amazon Read our detailed assessment ↓

EarthWay

EarthWay 40lb Residential Broadcast Spreader (2600A-Plus)

Buy it

A compact 40 lb broadcast spreader with EarthWay's EVEN-SPREAD three-hole drop, side-spread control and pneumatic tires.

Best for: Small to medium lawns where you want edge control and pneumatic tires without paying for a commercial spreader.

$$ · mid-range

Why we like it

• EarthWay's EVEN-SPREAD three-hole system is designed for balanced coverage, and side-spread control protects sidewalks and beds.
• 9-inch pneumatic tires, a rustproof hopper and solid linkage rate control, with a rate calculation matrix included.
• A low-profile design makes it easier to steer and store than full-size commercial models.

Know before buying

• EarthWay's warranty is 1 year, half of Brinly's and Chapin's.
• The 40 lb hopper is the smallest of the push spreaders here.
• The rain cover is sold separately.

Find it on Amazon Read our detailed assessment ↓

Chapin

Chapin TurfPro 80 Pound Broadcast Lawn Spreader (89200A)

Buy it

A big-hopper residential spreader rated for 18,000 sq. ft., with 12-inch pneumatic tires and an adjustable edge baffle.

Best for: Owners of large lawns who want fewer refill trips and a 2-year warranty.

$$ · mid-range

Why we like it

• The 80 lb poly hopper is rated by Chapin to cover 18,000 sq. ft., so large lawns need fewer refills.
• 12-inch pneumatic tires, an enclosed gearbox and a powder-coated steel frame suit grass and hills.
• An adjustable right baffle gives edge control, and it carries a 2-year limited warranty.

Know before buying

• Chapin designs it for residential use, so it is not meant for contractor duty.
• A full 80 lb hopper is a heavy load to push on slopes.
• Chapin says you must register the product to access the warranty.

Check price on Amazon Read our detailed assessment ↓

Agri-Fab

Agri-Fab 85 lb. Push Spreader Deluxe (45-0531)

It depends

A light 85 lb-capacity push spreader that covers about a quarter acre per fill, with edge control as an extra.

Best for: Buyers who want a big hopper in a light spreader and do not need edge control out of the box.

$$ · mid-range

Why we like it

• Agri-Fab says the 85 lb capacity covers about 1/4 acre (14,000 sq. ft.), depending on rate and material.
• At a listed 19 lbs it is light to lift and store, with 10-inch pneumatic wheels.
• Cable control and an enclosed gearbox are standard.

Know before buying

• The deflector kit, hopper cover and grate are sold separately, so edge control costs extra.
• The product page states no warranty term.
• Its 10-inch wheels are smaller than the Brinly's and Chapin's 12-inch tires.

Find it on Amazon Read our detailed assessment ↓

RYOBI

RYOBI 18V ONE+ Power Spreader (P2402BTL)

It depends

A battery-powered handheld spreader with a 1-gallon tub for small lawns, sold as a bare tool.

Best for: Small yards, spot seeding and owners already invested in RYOBI 18V batteries.

$ · budget

Why we like it

• RYOBI states a 1-gallon tub, coverage of up to 5,000 sq. ft. per tank and a spread width of up to 15 ft.
• An adjustable flow rate knob and spread lever control the output, and the motor removes the need to crank.
• It weighs 3 lbs and carries a 3-year limited warranty, the longest here.

Know before buying

• It is sold tool-only, so you need an 18V ONE+ battery and charger.
• One gallon means frequent refills on anything but a small lawn.
• You carry the full load by hand, unlike a push spreader.

Find it on Amazon Read our detailed assessment ↓

We'd skip it

Scotts

Scotts Turf Builder EdgeGuard DLX Broadcast Spreader (76232B)

Skip it

The familiar big-box spreader, with EdgeGuard edge control but plastic wheels, no mechanical warranty and weak owner ratings.

Best for: Only buyers who use Scotts products exclusively on a smooth lawn and accept a refund guarantee in place of a warranty.

$$ · mid-range

Why we like it

• EdgeGuard technology is built in to keep product off driveways, sidewalks and landscaping.
• It comes calibrated and ready to use out of the box, with no assembly.
• Scotts rates the hopper to hold product for up to 15,000 sq. ft., and settings are printed on Scotts bags.

Know before buying

• Scotts' own FAQ says the DLX has no mechanical warranty; it relies on a satisfaction guarantee with refunds within one year.
• It rolls on plastic open-spoke wheels, where every push spreader above has pneumatic tires.
• Scotts' own product page shows an average of 2.9 out of 5 from 1,087 ratings.
• Capacity is given only in square feet of Scotts product, and other fertilizers need a 4-step process to find a setting.

See our pick instead See it at Amazon anyway Read our detailed assessment ↓

How we judged the field

Five things decide whether a lawn spreader puts product where you want it. Hopper size and stated coverage tell you how often you will stop to refill. Tires matter more than they look: pneumatic tires keep the spinner turning evenly over bumps, while hard plastic wheels skid and bounce. Edge control, from a deflector, baffle or side-spread shutoff, keeps fertilizer and salt off beds and paving. An enclosed gearbox and corrosion-resistant hardware decide whether the spreader survives fertilizer and ice melt. And the warranty shows what the maker will stand behind.

The field splits into handhelds for small yards, residential push spreaders, and larger-hopper models for big lawns. We picked four push broadcast spreaders that publish their tires, gearbox and warranty, one battery handheld for small yards, and the big-box Scotts DLX because so many people buy it by default. If you are sorting out your lawn equipment, our cordless lawn mower comparison covers the other half of the job.

The Brinly P20-500BHDF-A is the best all-round spreader for a typical lawn because it gets the details right and includes the parts others sell separately. Brinly lists 12 x 3 inch pneumatic turf tires, a powder-coated steel frame, stainless steel hardware and a rust-resistant enclosed gearbox, and it states an 8 to 12 ft spread width. The 50 lb rust- and crack-proof poly hopper comes with a hopper screen, and the flip-up side deflector kit is in the box, so you can keep fertilizer off flower beds and salt off the lawn in winter. It is made in the USA and carries a 2-year warranty. The trade-offs are modest: it costs the most of the push spreaders here, the gears are plastic at a 5:1 ratio, and a 50 lb hopper means more refills on a large property than the 80 lb Chapin. For most suburban lawns, where edge control and durability matter more than raw capacity, it is the one to buy.

The EarthWay 2600A-Plus is the value pick for small to medium lawns. EarthWay builds it around its EVEN-SPREAD three-hole system for balanced coverage, adds side-spread control to protect sidewalks and beds, and rides on 9-inch pneumatic tires with a rustproof 40 lb hopper. Solid linkage rate control and an included rate calculation matrix help you dial in fertilizer or seed, and EarthWay says the low-profile design improves maneuverability and storage. It handles fertilizer, grass seed, grain and other granular materials. The compromises are capacity and coverage: 40 lb is the smallest push hopper here, the rain cover is extra, and EarthWay’s warranty is 1 year on all its products, half of what Brinly and Chapin offer. For a smaller lawn where you want real edge control and pneumatic tires at a lower price, it is a smart buy.

The Chapin TurfPro 80 Pound Broadcast Lawn Spreader (89200A) is the pick for larger lawns. Its 80 lb weather-resistant poly hopper is rated by Chapin to cover 18,000 sq. ft., and it rolls on 12-inch pneumatic tires that Chapin says give traction on grass and hills. An adjustable right baffle provides edge control, a gate dial adjusts the opening for different particle sizes, and the enclosed gearbox and powder-coated steel frame are built for wet conditions. The handle flips up for storage, and Chapin backs it with a 2-year limited warranty, though you need to register the product to access it. Chapin designs it for residential use, so it is not a contractor machine, and a full 80 lb load is a lot to push on a slope. Chapin also recommends against power washing it. For a big lawn where fewer refill trips matter, it is a strong choice.

The Agri-Fab 85 lb. Push Spreader Deluxe (45-0531) offers a big hopper in a light frame. Agri-Fab says its 85 lb capacity covers about 1/4 acre, or 14,000 sq. ft., depending on application rate and material, and lists the spreader at just 19 lbs, so it is easy to lift into a truck or hang in a garage. Cable control, an enclosed gearbox and 10-inch pneumatic wheels are standard. The catch is that edge control is not: the deflector kit, hopper cover and grate kit are sold separately, so the price climbs if you need to protect beds or paths. The product page also states no warranty term, and its 10-inch wheels are smaller than the 12-inch tires on the Brinly and Chapin. For open lawns without many edges, where a light spreader with a large hopper is the priority, it depends on whether you will add the deflector.

The RYOBI 18V ONE+ Power Spreader (P2402BTL) is a handheld for small jobs. RYOBI states a 1-gallon tub that covers up to 5,000 sq. ft. per tank, a spread width of up to 15 ft, an adjustable flow rate knob and a spread lever to choose the width. It weighs 3 lbs, and the battery motor means no cranking, which helps on long passes. RYOBI backs it with a 3-year limited warranty, the longest here. The limits are built into the format: it is sold tool-only, so you need an 18V ONE+ battery and charger, a gallon goes quickly on a large lawn, and you carry every pound by hand. It suits small front yards, patching bare spots with seed, and anyone who already owns RYOBI 18V batteries. For a lawn of any real size, a push spreader is the better tool.

The Scotts Turf Builder EdgeGuard DLX is the spreader many people pick up by default, and Scotts’ own page explains why it is the one to skip. It has real strengths: EdgeGuard technology keeps product off driveways and landscaping, it arrives calibrated with no assembly, and Scotts rates it to hold enough product for up to 15,000 sq. ft. But Scotts’ FAQ says the DLX has no mechanical warranty, relying instead on a satisfaction guarantee with refunds within one year of purchase. It rolls on plastic open-spoke wheels, where every push spreader above uses pneumatic tires. Capacity is stated only in square feet of Scotts product, and non-Scotts fertilizers need a 4-step process to find a setting. And on Scotts’ own product page, owners rate it an average of 2.9 out of 5 across 1,087 ratings. For similar money, a spreader with pneumatic tires and a real warranty is the better buy.

Brinly 50 LB. Push Spreader with Side Deflector & Hopper Cover (P20-500BHDF-A) vs EarthWay 40lb Residential Broadcast Spreader (2600A-Plus): which should you buy?

The Brinly P20-500BHDF-A and the EarthWay 2600A-Plus both have pneumatic tires and edge control, so either will spread more evenly than a plastic-wheeled big-box model. The Brinly is the more complete package: bigger 12 x 3 inch tires, a 50 lb hopper, stainless hardware, a stated 8 to 12 ft spread, a deflector and hopper screen in the box, US manufacture and a 2-year warranty. The EarthWay is smaller and cheaper, with a 40 lb hopper, 9-inch tires, EarthWay’s EVEN-SPREAD three-hole system, side-spread control and a 1-year warranty.

Choose the Brinly if you have a medium or larger lawn, spread salt in winter, or want the longer warranty. Choose the EarthWay if your lawn is small to medium, storage space is tight, and you would rather save the difference. If your lawn is large enough that refills become the problem, step up to the 80 lb Chapin instead.

Who should buy which

• Most suburban lawns: the Brinly 50 LB. Push Spreader with Side Deflector & Hopper Cover (P20-500BHDF-A). Pneumatic tires, an included deflector and a 2-year warranty in a US-made spreader.
• Budget buyers with small to medium lawns: the EarthWay 40lb Residential Broadcast Spreader (2600A-Plus). Edge control and pneumatic tires at a lower price.
• Large lawns: the Chapin TurfPro 80 Pound Broadcast Lawn Spreader (89200A). An 80 lb hopper rated for 18,000 sq. ft. and a 2-year warranty.
• Open lawns where weight matters: the Agri-Fab 85 lb. Push Spreader Deluxe (45-0531). An 85 lb hopper on a 19 lb spreader.
• Small yards on RYOBI batteries: the RYOBI 18V ONE+ Power Spreader (P2402BTL). A 3 lb battery handheld with a 3-year warranty.

What to look for

• Pneumatic tires: air-filled tires keep the spread even over bumps and push more easily than plastic wheels.
• Edge control included: a deflector, baffle or side-spread shutoff keeps product off beds and paving.
• Enclosed gearbox: a sealed gearbox keeps fertilizer and moisture out of the drive.
• Corrosion-resistant build: poly hoppers, coated frames and stainless hardware survive fertilizer and salt.
• Hopper sized to your lawn: match capacity and stated coverage to your square footage to limit refills.
• A real warranty: check the term and conditions, since some spreaders offer only a refund guarantee.

Our final take

For most lawns the Brinly P20-500BHDF-A is the spreader to buy: big pneumatic tires, an enclosed gearbox, stainless hardware, a deflector in the box and a 2-year warranty from a US maker. If you have a smaller lawn or budget, the EarthWay 2600A-Plus gives you the essentials for less. Large properties should look at the Chapin TurfPro 80 lb, light-duty open lawns at the Agri-Fab 85 lb, and small yards at the RYOBI handheld. Skip the Scotts EdgeGuard DLX: plastic wheels, no mechanical warranty and weak ratings on its own maker’s page are a poor trade for convenience.

Deciding between the top two? See our head-to-head: Brinly 50 LB. Push Spreader with Side Deflector & Hopper Cover (P20-500BHDF-A) vs EarthWay 40lb Residential Broadcast Spreader (2600A-Plus).

More in Garden & Outdoor Living

Lawn Spreaders, Explained Plain-English guide → Brinly 50 LB. Push Spreader with Side Deflector & Hopper Cover (P20-500BHDF-A) vs EarthWay 40lb Residential Broadcast Spreader (2600A-Plus) Head-to-head → The Best Cordless Leaf Blowers: 4 Compared (and One to Skip) The Best Outdoor Gas Griddles: 4 Compared (and One to Skip) The Best Patio Heaters: 4 Compared (and One to Skip) The Best Patio Umbrellas: 6 Compared (and One to Skip)