Home & Kitchen
The Best Tortilla Presses: 4 Compared (and One to Skip)
We compared Victoria's cast iron, a handmade hardwood press, a budget cast-iron and an electric tortilla cooker on size, material and what makes corn tortillas actually work.
The short version
The Victoria 8-inch cast iron is the tortilla press to gift - Colombian original, flaxseed-seasoned, $60. The Central Coast hardwood press is the $110 US-made heirloom. The Uno Casa is the $32 budget it-depends. Skip the Brentwood electric - it can't press corn masa at all.
Our picks at a glance
- Victoria 8-Inch Cast Iron Tortilla Press - Buy. The original cast-iron press - HD spherrous iron, flaxseed-seasoned, made in Colombia - $60.
- Central Coast Woodworks Hardwood Tortilla Press 10" - Buy. Handmade oak and walnut, 10-inch plate, built in the US by artisans - the heirloom at $110.
- Uno Casa Cast Iron Tortilla Press - It depends. The preseasoned budget cast-iron press - same job, half the Victoria's price, $32.
- Brentwood TS-128 Electric Tortilla Maker - Skip. A 10-inch electric cooker with nonstick plates - presses and cooks flour tortillas, but can't do corn masa.
The verdict in 30 seconds
What mattered most
- Material
- Plate size
- Corn masa
- Cooks the tortilla
- Origin
- Price class
A tortilla press is a slab of metal or wood that flattens masa - the simplest machine in the kitchen and one of the best gifts. The standard is cast iron; the heirloom choice is hardwood; the trap is an electric cooker that can't press corn at all. We compared Victoria's iron, Central Coast Woodworks' oak and walnut, a budget cast-iron and a plug-in tortilla maker.
The original cast-iron press - HD spherrous iron, flaxseed-seasoned, made in Colombia - $60.
Best for: The definitive tortilla-press gift - the machine that makes corn tortillas what they should be.
- The reference press: cast in Colombia since 1939 - the design everyone else copies.
- 8-inch plates - the corn tortilla standard; presses tortillas, patacones, arepas, roti and empanada dough.
- Seasoned with flaxseed oil at the factory - no synthetic coatings, paints or petrochemicals on the plates.
- HD spherrous iron is heavier-duty than the base cast iron - flatter plates, truer press.
- A lifetime tool - iron this simple doesn't wear out.
- $60 for a cast-iron press - premium over the budget copies doing the same job.
- 8-inch tops out at taco size - burrito-size flour tortillas need rolling.
- Cast iron needs the usual care - dry it, oil it, no dishwasher.
Handmade oak and walnut, 10-inch plate, built in the US by artisans - the heirloom at $110.
Best for: The keepsake gift - for the cook who values craft and makes flour tortillas as much as corn.
- Handmade in the US from solid oak and walnut - each press is a one-of-one piece of woodwork.
- 10-inch plate - presses large flour tortillas the 8-inch irons can't.
- Hardwood pressing is gentler on masa - no sticking, and wood doesn't need seasoning like iron.
- The gift that looks like a gift - a finished hardwood tool, not a kitchen implement.
- $110 is heirloom money - triple the iron press for the same function.
- Wood flexes differently than iron - the press is gentler, less uniform on very thin corn tortillas.
- Wood care applies - hand wash, dry, occasional oil.
The preseasoned budget cast-iron press - same job, half the Victoria's price, $32.
Best for: The budget buyer - a working press for occasional tortillas; the Victoria is the upgrade path.
- $32 for a preseasoned cast-iron press - the function for about half the Victoria.
- Presses flour and corn tortillas, quesadillas, empanadas - the full flatbread range.
- Preseasoned out of the box - ready to press.
- Bundled with a comal pan in a $55 set - the whole tortilla setup for less than the Victoria alone.
- Lighter casting and looser tolerances than the Victoria - press evenness is the gamble.
- Budget preseasoning wears - plan to re-season.
- The value brand of the category - no heritage, just the commodity.
A 10-inch electric cooker with nonstick plates - presses and cooks flour tortillas, but can't do corn masa.
Best for: A flour-tortilla-only household that wants push-button cooking. For the gift of real tortillas - corn included - buy the iron or the wood.
- Presses and cooks in one appliance - raw flour dough in, cooked 10-inch tortilla out.
- Adjustable heat for soft or crispy - more control than a comal gives a beginner.
- Nonstick plates and indicator lights - a real appliance, not a toy.
- It can't make corn tortillas - nixtamalized masa is too fragile for the cooking plates; electric makers are flour-only devices.
- A unitasker that replaces two tools - a $32 press and a pan do more.
- Nonstick plates wear - the coating is the appliance's shelf life.
- No disclosed US retail price on Brentwood's own store (listed at $0) - a distribution ghost.
| Criteria | Victoria 8-Inch Cast Iron Tortilla Press Top pick | Central Coast Woodworks Hardwood Tortilla Press 10" | Uno Casa Cast Iron Tortilla Press | Brentwood TS-128 Electric Tortilla Maker |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Verdict | Buy it | Buy it | It depends | Skip it |
| Best for | The definitive tortilla-press gift - the machine that makes corn tortillas what they should be. | The keepsake gift - for the cook who values craft and makes flour tortillas as much as corn. | The budget buyer - a working press for occasional tortillas; the Victoria is the upgrade path. | A flour-tortilla-only household that wants push-button cooking. For the gift of real tortillas - corn included - buy the iron or the wood. |
| Price tier | $$ · mid-range | $$$ · premium | $ · budget | $$ · mid-range |
| Material | HD cast iron | Solid oak + walnut | Cast iron | Nonstick electric plates |
| Plate size | 8 inch | 10 inch | 8 inch | 10 inch |
| Corn masa | Yes | Yes | Yes | No - flour only |
| Cooks the tortilla | No - press only | No - press only | No - press only | Yes - heats too |
| Origin | Made in Colombia | Handmade in US | Imported | Imported appliance |
| Price class | $60 | $110 | $32 | $45-70 street |
Which one is right for you?
- The definitive tortilla-press gift - the machine that makes corn tortillas what they should be. Buy it Victoria 8-Inch Cast Iron Tortilla Press
- The keepsake gift - for the cook who values craft and makes flour tortillas as much as corn. Buy it Central Coast Woodworks Hardwood Tortilla Press 10"
- The budget buyer - a working press for occasional tortillas; the Victoria is the upgrade path. It depends Uno Casa Cast Iron Tortilla Press
- A flour-tortilla-only household that wants push-button cooking. For the gift of real tortillas - corn included - buy the iron or the wood. Skip it Brentwood TS-128 Electric Tortilla Maker
How we judged the field
A tortilla press is the simplest machine in the kitchen - a plate and a lever for masa. The standard is cast iron, the heirloom is hardwood, and the wrong answer is an electric cooker that can’t press corn at all. We compared Victoria’s iron, Central Coast Woodworks’ oak and walnut, a budget cast-iron and a plug-in tortilla maker on plate size, material and who each is actually for.
The Victoria is the reference: cast in Colombia since 1939, HD spherrous iron, 8-inch plates, factory-seasoned with flaxseed oil. $60.
It presses everything - corn tortillas, arepas, patacones, empanadas, roti - and the seasoning is clean: no paints, no synthetics. 8 inches tops out at taco size and cast iron wants the usual care, but this is the press other presses are measured against.
The CCWW press is the heirloom: solid oak and walnut, handmade in the US, a 10-inch plate that presses flour tortillas the iron can’t reach. $110.
It’s the most gift-like object in the lineup - a finished piece of woodwork, not an implement. Hardwood presses gentler than iron and at $110 it’s triple the price, but for a cook who values craft it’s the one they’d put on a shelf.
The Uno Casa is the budget iron: preseasoned cast iron, 8-inch, pressing the full flatbread range for $32.
Whether it’s enough depends on volume. The casting is lighter and the tolerances looser than the Victoria - occasional tortillas, fine; a weekly press-and-comal ritual will outgrow it. Half the price buys the function; the extra money buys flatness.
The Brentwood is the appliance answer: a 10-inch electric cooker with nonstick plates and adjustable heat that presses and cooks flour tortillas in one step.
The problem is category error: electric tortilla makers can’t do corn masa - the nixtamalized dough is too fragile for the cooking plates, so this is a flour-only unitasker that still can’t make the tortilla a press exists for. Add a real press plus a comal and you get more for less. Skip it.
Victoria vs Central Coast: which should you buy?
The Victoria is the $60 iron standard; the Central Coast is the $110 handmade hardwood heirloom.
Buy the Victoria for the cook - it’s the tool, full stop. Buy the Central Coast for the gift - when the object itself should carry the meaning, wood wins.
What to look for
- Corn needs a press, not a cooker: electric tortilla makers are flour-only devices - masa requires a press plus a comal.
- 8-inch is the corn standard; 10-inch for flour.
- Iron presses harder, wood presses gentler: iron for thin, uniform corn; wood for craft and size.
- Seasoning is the spec: flaxseed-seasoned iron beats mystery coatings.
- The plastic-liner trick is universal: every press needs a liner between dough and plate - that’s technique, not a flaw.
Our final take
The Victoria 8-inch cast iron is the tortilla press to gift - the Colombian original, flaxseed-seasoned, $60. The Central Coast hardwood press is the $110 heirloom for the craft-minded. The Uno Casa is the $32 budget entry. Skip the Brentwood electric - it can’t make a corn tortilla. Buy the iron, line it with plastic, press corn.
Questions, answered
Cast iron or wooden tortilla press?
Iron is the standard: heavier, presses thinner, more uniform - and it's what Mexican kitchens use. Hardwood is the artisan option: gentler on dough, usually 10-inch, beautiful enough to gift. Iron for corn-tortilla purists; wood for craft and flour size.
Can an electric tortilla maker press corn tortillas?
No - and this is the category's dirty secret. Electric tortilla/roti makers cook flour dough on nonstick plates; nixtamalized corn masa is too delicate and wet for them. Corn needs a press plus a comal or hot pan.
What size tortilla press should I get?
8-inch for corn tortillas - it's the taco standard. 10-inch if flour tortillas are the point. A press makes the circle size; cooking happens on a comal or skillet.
Do I need a comal too?
Yes - a press shapes raw dough; you still cook the tortilla on a hot comal or cast-iron pan. That's why the electric cooker's promise is misleading: it cooks, but only flour, and it can't make the corn tortilla the press exists for.
How do you keep masa from sticking to the press?
Line the plates with plastic - a cut grocery bag or parchment - between dough and metal. Every press needs it; it's not a defect, it's the technique.
Deciding between the top two? See our head-to-head: Victoria 8-Inch Cast Iron Tortilla Press vs Central Coast Woodworks Hardwood Tortilla Press 10".
More Home & Kitchen reviews
The Best Touchless Kitchen Trash Cans: 4 Compared (and One to Skip) 
The Best Tower Fans: 4 Compared (and One to Skip) 
The Best Travel Mugs: 4 Compared (and One to Skip) 
The Best Vacuum Sealers: 4 Compared (and One to Skip) 
The Best Waffle Makers: 4 Compared (and One to Skip) 
The Best Water Filter Pitchers: 4 Compared (and One to Skip)