Tools & DIY · Head-to-head

xTool S1 vs AtomStack A20 Pro V2

Which should you buy? Our verdict on both, pulled from our full Laser Engravers: Which to Buy and Which to Skip comparison.

The xTool S1 combines an enclosed body, a big bed and swappable modules, and its maker lists Class 1 safety with flame detection and a lid-open stop. The AtomStack A20 Pro V2 delivers 20W and a 400 x 365 mm bed in an open frame for much less.

xTool S1

xTool S1

Buy it

An enclosed 40W diode machine with a big bed and the most complete safety feature list in this group.

  • The 40W bundle lists a 19.6 x 12.5 in (498 x 319 mm) working area, 600 mm/s working speed and a 0.08 x 0.10 mm spot size.
  • Enclosed build: the maker lists Class 1 safety, 5-direction flame detection, an emergency stop, a lid-open safety stop and a laser key lock.
  • Switchable modules (40W, 20W, 10W diode, plus a separate 1064nm IR kit for metal) and a conveyor-feeder option for long projects up to 118 in.
  • It is the most expensive of the three machines most buyers will cross-shop.
  • The maker lists separate Class 1 and Class 4 riser bases, so check which riser you are adding.
  • At 20 kg and 30.12 x 22.09 in, it needs a dedicated bench or table.
Find it on Amazon
AtomStack A20 Pro V2

AtomStack A20 Pro V2

Buy it

A 20W open-frame diode laser with a large bed at a fraction of the enclosed-machine cost.

  • 20W diode laser at 455 nm with a 0.08 x 0.10 mm spot and a 400 x 365 mm (15.75 x 15.4 in) engraving area.
  • Maker lists USB and 2.4G Wi-Fi, LightBurn and LaserGRBL support, and a tip-over alarm that sounds above a 15 degree tilt.
  • Quality certifications listed by the maker: IEC 60825, CE, FCC, RoHS, FDA, PSE and UKCA, and the machine can be bought alone or in bundles that include an enclosure.
  • The machine-only listing is an open frame, so the lid, eye protection and smoke handling are on you or the enclosure bundle.
  • Focus is manual, and speed tops out at 400 mm/s.
  • Flame detection is listed as requiring the Z2 Z-axis slider.
Check price on Amazon

Side by side

The 8 criteria below are the ones our full comparison judged every product on, narrowed to these two.

xTool S1 Our pickAtomStack A20 Pro V2
Our verdictBuyBuy
Best forHobbyists who want one enclosed machine to grow into rather than outgrow.Budget-minded buyers with a garage or workshop who want real cutting power.
Price tier$$$ · premium$$ · mid-range
Laser type and powerDiode, 40W module (20W/10W optional)Diode, 20W
Work area19.6 x 12.5 in15.75 x 15.4 in
EnclosureEnclosed with lidOpen frame (enclosure bundle sold)
Laser class as stated by makerClass 1 safety listedNot published on listing (IEC 60825 certification listed)
Listed safety featuresFlame detection, e-stop, lid-open stop, key lockTip-over alarm, flame detection (needs Z2 slider)
Cooling and smoke handlingExhaust fans, purifier sold separatelyOpen frame, air assist listed
Connectivity and softwareUSB, Wi-Fi, xTool Creative Space, LightBurnUSB, 2.4G Wi-Fi, LightBurn, LaserGRBL
Best forGrowing hobbyistsValue seekers

Which one is right for you?

Pick the xTool S1 if

hobbyists who want one enclosed machine to grow into rather than outgrow.

Know before buying: it is the most expensive of the three machines most buyers will cross-shop.

Pick the AtomStack A20 Pro V2 if

budget-minded buyers with a garage or workshop who want real cutting power.

Know before buying: the machine-only listing is an open frame, so the lid, eye protection and smoke handling are on you or the enclosure bundle.

The bottom line

Our overall pick is the xTool S1 - An enclosed 40W diode machine with a big bed and the most complete safety feature list in this group. Choose the AtomStack A20 Pro V2 instead if budget-minded buyers with a garage or workshop who want real cutting power.

Want the full picture, including the other options we compared and the popular one we'd skip? Read the complete Laser Engravers: Which to Buy and Which to Skip.