Coffee & Espresso · Head-to-head
OXO Brew Compact Cold Brew Coffee Maker vs Toddy Cold Brew System
Which should you buy? Our verdict on both, pulled from our full The Best Cold Brew Coffee Makers: 4 Compared (and One to Skip) comparison.
The OXO wins for most kitchens on the strength of even extraction, effortless draining, and a glass carafe that stays taste-neutral. The Toddy is the pick for anyone who brews concentrate in bulk and wants the smoothest, lowest-acid result the group can produce.
OXO Brew Compact Cold Brew Coffee Maker
Buy itThe easiest all-rounder: a perforated rainmaker lid wets grounds evenly and the brew drains on its own once set on the glass carafe.
- Rainmaker lid saturates grounds evenly, which reviewers link to a consistently smooth concentrate
- Drains automatically once the brewing container is set on the glass carafe, with far less mess than pouring
- Reusable mesh filter and glass carafe avoid the plastic-taste complaints of all-plastic rivals
- Compact footprint fits a crowded counter or fridge shelf
- The compact batch size is small for a heavy-drinking household
- Owners occasionally report minor dripping during the brew step
Toddy Cold Brew System
Buy itThe original concentrate system still makes the smoothest, lowest-acid brew of the group thanks to its felt filtration.
- Felt filtration produces exceptionally clean, low-acid concentrate that reviewers rate above mesh-filtered rivals
- Yields about 36 to 38 ounces of concentrate per 12-ounce batch of coffee, which Toddy says keeps up to 2 weeks in the fridge
- Simple BPA-free plastic brewing container, glass decanter and a silicone stopper drain
- Two reusable felt filters in the box, each good for up to 10 brews
- Felt filters must be rinsed and stored sealed in the freezer, and replaced after 10 uses or 3 months, adding ongoing cost and upkeep
- Setup and draining are more hands-on and messier than self-draining designs like the OXO
Side by side
The 7 criteria below are the ones our full comparison judged every product on, narrowed to these two.
| OXO Brew Compact Cold Brew Coffee Maker Our pick | Toddy Cold Brew System | |
|---|---|---|
| Our verdict | Buy | Buy |
| Best for | Most people who want low-effort, smooth concentrate without babysitting the process or replacing filters. | Concentrate devotees who prioritize the smoothest, least acidic cup and brew in bulk. |
| Price tier | $$ · mid-range | $$ · mid-range |
| Brew style | Concentrate | Concentrate |
| Filter type | Reusable mesh | Reusable felt |
| Batch size | Small (compact) | Large (36 to 38 oz concentrate) |
| Cleanup and draining | Very easy (drains onto carafe) | Hands-on, messier |
| Body material | Glass carafe + plastic top | Plastic + glass decanter |
| Flavor and clarity | Smooth, clean | Smoothest, lowest acid |
| Ongoing cost | None (reusable mesh) | Felt filters replaced after 10 uses |
Which one is right for you?
Pick the OXO Brew Compact Cold Brew Coffee Maker if
most people who want low-effort, smooth concentrate without babysitting the process or replacing filters.
Know before buying: the compact batch size is small for a heavy-drinking household.
Pick the Toddy Cold Brew System if
concentrate devotees who prioritize the smoothest, least acidic cup and brew in bulk.
Know before buying: felt filters must be rinsed and stored sealed in the freezer, and replaced after 10 uses or 3 months, adding ongoing cost and upkeep.
The bottom line
Our overall pick is the OXO Brew Compact Cold Brew Coffee Maker - The easiest all-rounder: a perforated rainmaker lid wets grounds evenly and the brew drains on its own once set on the glass carafe. Choose the Toddy Cold Brew System instead if concentrate devotees who prioritize the smoothest, least acidic cup and brew in bulk.
Want the full picture, including the other options we compared and the popular one we'd skip? Read the complete The Best Cold Brew Coffee Makers: 4 Compared (and One to Skip).