Pets · Head-to-head
Bulldogology Premium Pet Training Pads (24 x 24 in) vs HoneyCare All-Absorb Dog and Puppy Training Pads
Which should you buy? Our verdict on both, pulled from our full The Best Puppy Pads: 4 Compared (and One to Skip) comparison.
Bulldogology publishes more checkable detail than anyone else here, including a polymer weight and an absorbency figure tied to a specific sheet size, and it is the only pad in this group whose own page confirms adhesive tabs. HoneyCare gets you the same 6 layer, gel core construction across four sizes for less, provided you can live without the tabs and without a published capacity number.
Bulldogology Premium Pet Training Pads (24 x 24 in)
Buy itThe only pad here whose maker publishes a polymer weight, a capacity figure and adhesive tabs on the same page.
- The maker states a 6 layer build with 5 g of super absorbent polymer that converts liquid to gel.
- Adhesive tabs on the pad corners are listed as optional, so you can anchor the pad or leave the tabs covered.
- Four sheet sizes are offered on the maker's site: 24 by 24, 24 by 35, 30 by 30 and 30 by 36 inches.
- The stated capacity of up to 7 to 9 or more cups applies to the 24 by 24 inch sheet, and the maker does not publish separate figures for the larger sizes.
- The built-in attractant claim is presented without any evidence, so do not pay a premium for it.
- Odour control is described as blocking and neutralising odours, which is a claim rather than a measured spec.
HoneyCare All-Absorb Dog and Puppy Training Pads
Buy itSix layers and a gel core in four clearly stated sizes, sold in bulk counts that keep the per-sheet cost low.
- The maker lists 6 premium inner layers and a super absorbent gel core, the same basic construction as the premium pick.
- Four sheet sizes are stated outright: 17.5 by 23.5, 22 by 23, 28 by 34 and 30 by 36 inches.
- Bulk counts of 160 to 480 pads bring the per-sheet cost down for high-volume households.
- The current product page does not publish an absorbency figure in cups or millilitres, so you cannot compare capacity directly.
- Adhesive tabs are not listed on the maker's page, so plan on a pad holder if your dog moves the pad.
- Odour eliminating is claimed across the range without supporting data.
Side by side
The 8 criteria below are the ones our full comparison judged every product on, narrowed to these two.
| Bulldogology Premium Pet Training Pads (24 x 24 in) Our pick | HoneyCare All-Absorb Dog and Puppy Training Pads | |
|---|---|---|
| Our verdict | Buy | Buy |
| Best for | Someone with a hard floor and a pad-shredding puppy who wants the pad pinned down and the numbers spelled out. | High-volume households, whelping boxes and anyone changing pads often enough that per-sheet cost is the deciding factor. |
| Price tier | $$$ · premium | $ · budget |
| Type | Disposable | Disposable |
| Sheet sizes on maker's page | 24 x 24, 24 x 35, 30 x 30, 30 x 36 in | 17.5 x 23.5, 22 x 23, 28 x 34, 30 x 36 in |
| Layers claimed | 6 | 6 inner layers |
| Absorbency claimed | Up to 7 to 9+ cups (24 x 24 in) | Not published |
| Gel core | Yes, 5 g super absorbent polymer stated | Yes, super absorbent gel core |
| Adhesive tabs | Yes, on corners, optional | Not listed |
| Attractant claim | Claimed | Built-in attractant claimed |
| Added fragrance | None listed | None listed |
Which one is right for you?
Pick the Bulldogology Premium Pet Training Pads (24 x 24 in) if
someone with a hard floor and a pad-shredding puppy who wants the pad pinned down and the numbers spelled out.
Know before buying: the stated capacity of up to 7 to 9 or more cups applies to the 24 by 24 inch sheet, and the maker does not publish separate figures for the larger sizes.
Pick the HoneyCare All-Absorb Dog and Puppy Training Pads if
high-volume households, whelping boxes and anyone changing pads often enough that per-sheet cost is the deciding factor.
Know before buying: the current product page does not publish an absorbency figure in cups or millilitres, so you cannot compare capacity directly.
The bottom line
Our overall pick is the Bulldogology Premium Pet Training Pads (24 x 24 in) - The only pad here whose maker publishes a polymer weight, a capacity figure and adhesive tabs on the same page. Choose the HoneyCare All-Absorb Dog and Puppy Training Pads instead if high-volume households, whelping boxes and anyone changing pads often enough that per-sheet cost is the deciding factor.
Want the full picture, including the other options we compared and the popular one we'd skip? Read the complete The Best Puppy Pads: 4 Compared (and One to Skip).