Baby & Family · Head-to-head

Prevelo Alpha Three vs Guardian Bikes Guardian 20 Inch Small Bike

Which should you buy? Our verdict on both, pulled from our full The Best Kids Bikes: 6 Compared (and One to Skip) comparison.

The Prevelo Alpha Three combines a listed 16.9 pounds without pedals with hydraulic disc brakes, 8 speeds and a clear inseam range. The Guardian 20 Inch Small Bike gets a child onto a simple, well-equipped bike for much less.

Prevelo Alpha Three

Prevelo Alpha Three

Buy it

A 20 inch aluminum bike with 8 speeds and hydraulic disc brakes, listed by Prevelo at 16.9 pounds without pedals.

  • Prevelo lists 16.9 pounds without pedals and a recommended inseam of 19 to 23 inches, with a saddle that runs from 21.2 to 26.4 inches.
  • Promax hydraulic disc brakes, an 8-speed Microshift drivetrain with an 11-38t cassette and chain retention, and a one-piece bar and stem Prevelo describes as kid-specific.
  • Prevelo describes a triple-butted 6061 aluminum frame with internal cable routing, a low standover of 16.53 inches and tubeless-compatible rims.
  • It is the first geared bike in the Alpha range, and Prevelo pitches it at kids who have already mastered pedaling and bike handling, so a true beginner may not need it.
  • A kickstand is not in the spec list and is sold by Prevelo as a separate accessory.
  • Prevelo does not publish a maximum rider weight on the product page.
Find it on Amazon
Guardian Bikes Guardian 20 Inch Small Bike

Guardian Bikes Guardian 20 Inch Small Bike

Buy it

A steel 20 inch bike for ages 5 to 8 built around Guardian's single-lever SureStop brake and a kickstand in the box.

  • Guardian lists ages 5 to 8 and a rider height of 43 to 51 inches, with a 20 inch large version for ages 6 to 9 if your child is taller.
  • The SureStop system is a single lever that Guardian says balances front and rear braking automatically, and Guardian describes it as easier to use.
  • The kit includes a kickstand, four reflectors, pedals, a wrench and a tool kit, and Guardian lists the bike as compatible with training wheels.
  • Guardian lists 20.7 pounds, several pounds more than the woom GO 4 and the Prevelo Alpha Three.
  • It is a steel frame with no gears listed, so it suits flat neighborhoods more than hills.
  • A single-lever brake works differently from the two-lever layout on bikes like the woom GO 4, so a child who moves up later will learn a new setup.
Find it on Amazon

Side by side

The 9 criteria below are the ones our full comparison judged every product on, narrowed to these two.

Prevelo Alpha Three Our pickGuardian Bikes Guardian 20 Inch Small Bike
Our verdictBuyBuy
Best forA confident 5 to 9 year old who will ride paths and light trails and is ready for gears and disc brakes.Families who want a proven first pedal bike with simple braking and the accessories included.
Price tier$$$ · premium$$ · mid-range
Wheel size20 in20 in
Maker's age range5 to 9 years5 to 8 years
Maker's height or inseamInseam 19 to 23 inHeight 43 to 51 in
Weight (maker's figure)16.9 lb (without pedals)20.7 lb
Gears8-speedNone listed
BrakesHydraulic discSingle-lever SureStop
Frame6061 aluminumSteel
Kickstand in the boxSold separatelyYes
Max rider weightNot publishedNot published

Which one is right for you?

Pick the Prevelo Alpha Three if

a confident 5 to 9 year old who will ride paths and light trails and is ready for gears and disc brakes.

Know before buying: it is the first geared bike in the Alpha range, and Prevelo pitches it at kids who have already mastered pedaling and bike handling, so a true beginner may not need it.

Pick the Guardian Bikes Guardian 20 Inch Small Bike if

families who want a proven first pedal bike with simple braking and the accessories included.

Know before buying: guardian lists 20.7 pounds, several pounds more than the woom GO 4 and the Prevelo Alpha Three.

The bottom line

Our overall pick is the Prevelo Alpha Three - A 20 inch aluminum bike with 8 speeds and hydraulic disc brakes, listed by Prevelo at 16.9 pounds without pedals. Choose the Guardian Bikes Guardian 20 Inch Small Bike instead if families who want a proven first pedal bike with simple braking and the accessories included.

Want the full picture, including the other options we compared and the popular one we'd skip? Read the complete The Best Kids Bikes: 6 Compared (and One to Skip).