Baby & Family · Head-to-head

Lortone 3A Rotary Tumbler vs Thames & Kosmos Rock Tumbler

Which should you buy? Our verdict on both, pulled from our full Rock Tumblers: Which to Buy and Which to Skip comparison.

The Lortone 3A is a simple, repairable hobby machine with a quiet all-rubber barrel and a maker booklet that spells out four grit stages. The Thames & Kosmos Rock Tumbler is the better first machine for a child, because it is the only one here that publishes full stage-by-stage timings, a built-in timer and an age warning in the manual.

Lortone 3A Rotary Tumbler

Lortone 3A Rotary Tumbler

Buy it

A plain hobby-grade tumbler with a single 3 lb all-rubber barrel that Lortone says suits stones up to 1-1/4 inches.

  • Lortone describes the all-rubber barrel as quiet and long wearing, molded with ribs to increase the tumbling action.
  • The booklet says Lortone tumblers can operate 24 hours a day for years with proper care, and that the motor needs no oiling.
  • The booklet gives a four-stage grit chart: 60/90 and 120/220 silicon carbide, then pre-polish and polish aluminum oxide.
  • The product page lists no grit, rough stones or jewelry fittings, so check what is in the box before treating it as a starter kit.
  • The page and booklet publish no age rating and no safety warnings for children.
  • The shaft bearings need one drop of light oil every 30 days of operation, and the page says the machine requires oiling.
Find it on Amazon
Thames & Kosmos Rock Tumbler

Thames & Kosmos Rock Tumbler

Buy it

A kid-oriented kit with a built-in timer of up to seven days, four grit packets and a USB-C power supply, rated by the maker for ages 8 and up.

  • The manual lists four grit packets (60, 220, 500 and 1200 grit) and suggests 4, 7, 7 and 7 days for the four stages, with 3 more days for best results.
  • It runs from a USB-C cable on a DC 5V adapter and has an over-current protection light, and the motor stops itself when the set days end.
  • The kit includes 200 g (7 oz) of assorted rocks, jewelry fittings, a strainer, a drip tray and a spare belt.
  • The barrel holds about 1 lb, and the manual says to fill it to one-half or two-thirds, so batches are small.
  • The USB power adapter is not in the box; the manual lists it under what you will also need.
  • The manual says the tumbler may move around when running, and the outer lid is pried off with a flat tool.
Check price on Amazon

Side by side

The 8 criteria below are the ones our full comparison judged every product on, narrowed to these two.

Lortone 3A Rotary Tumbler Our pickThames & Kosmos Rock Tumbler
Our verdictBuyBuy
Best forA hobbyist or a parent who will supervise the whole process and wants a machine that is built to be run for years.A child aged 8 or older who will do this with an adult, since the manual says adult supervision is required for the grit.
Price tier$$ · mid-range$ · budget
Tumbling typeRotary, rubber barrelRotary, rubber barrel
Capacity as statedOne 3 lb barrel1 lb barrel (450 g)
Grit in the boxNot listed on page4 packets, 60 to 1200 grit
Rough stones in the boxNot listed on page200 g (7 oz)
Maker run-time guidance2-3 days then check, 5-7 days before rinsing4, 7, 7, 7 days by stage
Power as statedPlug-in, rating not on pageUSB-C, DC 5V adapter not included
Built-in timerNot listedYes, 1 to 7 days
Age or supervision wordingNot statedOver 8, adult supervision for grit

Which one is right for you?

Pick the Lortone 3A Rotary Tumbler if

a hobbyist or a parent who will supervise the whole process and wants a machine that is built to be run for years.

Know before buying: the product page lists no grit, rough stones or jewelry fittings, so check what is in the box before treating it as a starter kit.

Pick the Thames & Kosmos Rock Tumbler if

a child aged 8 or older who will do this with an adult, since the manual says adult supervision is required for the grit.

Know before buying: the barrel holds about 1 lb, and the manual says to fill it to one-half or two-thirds, so batches are small.

The bottom line

Our overall pick is the Lortone 3A Rotary Tumbler - A plain hobby-grade tumbler with a single 3 lb all-rubber barrel that Lortone says suits stones up to 1-1/4 inches. Choose the Thames & Kosmos Rock Tumbler instead if a child aged 8 or older who will do this with an adult, since the manual says adult supervision is required for the grit.

Want the full picture, including the other options we compared and the popular one we'd skip? Read the complete Rock Tumblers: Which to Buy and Which to Skip.