Outdoors & Fitness · Head-to-head

K2 Raider Ice vs American Athletic Tricot Lined Figure Ice Skate

Which should you buy? Our verdict on both, pulled from our full Kids' Ice Skates: Which to Buy and Which to Skip comparison.

K2 publishes the most detail on sizes, blade and cuff, and expands five sizes per skate. American Athletic gives a fixed-size figure skate with a toe pick at the lowest tier.

K2 Raider Ice

K2 Raider Ice

Buy it

An adjustable beginner skate with a speed lace, a junior cuff and buckle, and a size chart that lists foot length in centimetres.

  • K2 states each skate expands five sizes and publishes four ranges (J8-12, 11-2, 1-5, 4-8), so a child can cover a wide span of sizes.
  • The page lists a stainless steel hockey blade, pre-sharpened, and an integrated blade mount that K2 says lowers a young skater's centre of gravity.
  • K2 describes a junior cuff with an integrated adjustable buckle plus a single-pull speed lace with a pouch on the tongue, which keeps getting dressed simple.
  • The maker page says the product is not available on K2's own site and sends you to a local store, so availability depends on your area.
  • It is a hockey-style blade rather than a figure blade, so there is no toe pick for children who want one.
  • K2 does not publish a numeric support rating, only the junior cuff and SoftBoot description.
Check price on Amazon
American Athletic Tricot Lined Figure Ice Skate

American Athletic Tricot Lined Figure Ice Skate

Buy it

A fixed-size, lace-up entry figure skate with padded liners, reinforced ankle support and a beginner-style toe pick.

  • The maker calls it its best selling entry level figure skate and lists padded inner liners with reinforced ankle support.
  • The blade is stainless steel with a beginner style toe pick, and the boot is a wipe clean material.
  • Sizes run from 8 Youth up to 4 with a size chart image on the page, and the maker says sizing is made for beginning lessons or family skating.
  • It is not adjustable, so a growing child needs a new pair at the next size change.
  • The page does not state a boot support rating or the liner material beyond tricot and padding.
  • A boys' version and a girls' version are listed separately, so check the colour and style you are buying.
Check price on Amazon

Side by side

The 8 criteria below are the ones our full comparison judged every product on, narrowed to these two.

K2 Raider Ice Our pickAmerican Athletic Tricot Lined Figure Ice Skate
Our verdictBuyBuy
Best forA beginner who will grow quickly and wants one pair across several sizes with a clear published size chart.A child taking beginner lessons or skating at a family rink who needs a simple fixed-size figure skate.
Price tier$$ · mid-range$ · budget
Skate typeRecreational, hockey-style bladeFigure
AdjustableYes, 5 sizesNo, fixed sizes
Smallest size listedJ88 Youth
Largest size listed84
Blade as statedStainless steel hockeyStainless steel, toe pick
Closure as statedSpeed lace, buckleLaces
Support rating publishedNoNo
Size chart on pageYes, with foot lengthYes, image

Which one is right for you?

Pick the K2 Raider Ice if

a beginner who will grow quickly and wants one pair across several sizes with a clear published size chart.

Know before buying: the maker page says the product is not available on K2's own site and sends you to a local store, so availability depends on your area.

Pick the American Athletic Tricot Lined Figure Ice Skate if

a child taking beginner lessons or skating at a family rink who needs a simple fixed-size figure skate.

Know before buying: it is not adjustable, so a growing child needs a new pair at the next size change.

The bottom line

Our overall pick is the K2 Raider Ice - An adjustable beginner skate with a speed lace, a junior cuff and buckle, and a size chart that lists foot length in centimetres. Choose the American Athletic Tricot Lined Figure Ice Skate instead if a child taking beginner lessons or skating at a family rink who needs a simple fixed-size figure skate.

Want the full picture, including the other options we compared and the popular one we'd skip? Read the complete Kids' Ice Skates: Which to Buy and Which to Skip.